Blog Layout

Restoring vs. Replacing Stone Countertops: Pros and Cons

Matthew Young • June 30, 2023

Many people love the look of natural stone countertops in their homes. Natural stone can add elegance to any home aesthetic. However, that elegance doesn’t last forever. Chemical cleaners, hard water, and human accidents can dull stone countertops to the point you must consider restoring or replacing them. There are pros and cons to each option, which we explain below.


Pros of Restoration: Keeping Countertops Beautiful and Intact

If you already have stone countertops in your home, you should do your best to maintain them. They are durable and will last a long time with proper care. Part of that proper care is occasional restorations. Restorations involve various processes based on what your stone needs, such as repairing chips with resin and cleaning solid countertops with special equipment.


There are many pros to restoring your countertops. You get to keep the beautiful countertops you already love. No deconstruction is required either. We can clean your countertops as they are.


Cons of Restoration: Delaying the Inevitable and Enduring Tools

Restoration isn’t the perfect solution for every stone countertop. Natural stone doesn’t last forever. If there are problems with the stone itself, not just its finish, restoration is a tiny bandage on a huge hole. Various restoration processes may help, but they won’t fix the bigger problems and will only delay the inevitable.


Since restoration occurs in your home, it can also disturb your home life. Professionals will bring tools and other supplies into your home and temporarily cut off access to your kitchen or bathroom.


Pros of Replacement: Elevate Aesthetics and Home Value

When you can’t salvage your stone countertops, you must replace them. You can find a similar stone to the original if you loved that design or embrace a new design. Whatever you choose, natural stone countertops will elevate your kitchen or bathroom aesthetics. They will make the space look elegant and sleek.


Replacing stone countertops isn’t just for you either. When you inevitably sell your home in the future, natural stone countertops can increase your home value. You’ll get more bang for your buck and leave the buyer with beautiful features.


Cons of Replacement: Expensive and Impermanent

While there are many pros to replacing your countertops, replacement isn’t the answer to every stone problem. Full replacement is expensive and often not worth the investment if most of the stone is in good shape. Many restoration methods can fix minor problems for a lower price tag.


Replacing stone countertops isn’t a permanent solution either. Eventually, these surfaces will break down under chemical cleaners, hard water, and human accidents, just as the original did. Whether the stone is new or old, you will need to perform regular maintenance.



There are many pros and cons to restoring and replacing stone countertops. You must choose what is best for your stone, your home, and your budget. Cleaner Image Marble can help you make that decision with our stone countertop restoration. We work hard to keep your stone beautiful and functioning well for as long as possible.ur new post

Making a Statement With Stone Floors and Countertops
August 19, 2024
Follow these expert tips and insights to discover how stone floors and countertops transform your home into a luxurious and timeless sanctuary.
A close-up view of a gray and white granite countertop. There are different types of fruit on the co
By Matthew Young August 2, 2024
Natural stone adds timeless visual appeal to any area in your home. Make the right choice for your space by understanding the different types of natural stone.
Lovely kitchen with a white marble floor with grey marbling attended by a small table and chair set.
June 20, 2024
Not all stones are the same, and it’s important to remember their differences to ensure you’re correctly maintaining your natural stone surfaces.
Stone Refinishing 101: Understanding the Basics
May 16, 2024
If you want to improve the look and extend the lifetime of your marble, granite, or other stone surfaces, here’s a quick course in stone refinishing.
How Natural Stone Restoration Revitalizes Your Outdoor Space
April 11, 2024
If you employ natural stone in your outdoor decor, consider setting up a restoration session. Better-looking stone is just one of the benefits!
The Impact of Stone Refinishing on Home Value
March 14, 2024
If you have natural stone anywhere in your home—the kitchen, the floors, or outside—refinishing is a great way to maintain if not increase your home’s value.
Stone Refinishing vs Restoration: What’s the Difference?
February 27, 2024
Stone refinishing and stone restoration are two options for bringing out or bringing back the luster of your slabs. What's the difference between the two?
Restoring Stone Tile Grout for a Fresh and Clean Look
February 2, 2024
Understand the importance of professional stone tile grout restoration for enhancing the appearance and longevity of your home or business’s tile surfaces.
Marble Refinishing 101: Understanding the Process
December 14, 2023
Explore Cleaner Image Marble's detailed guide to marble refinishing, from assessment to sealing, for enduring beauty and durability in your home or business.
Why You Should Trust a Professional for Stone Restoration
By Matthew Young November 8, 2023
Experts ensure safety, efficiency, and satisfaction in restoring your stone's luster and beauty. Cleaner Image Marble works on stone floors and other surfaces.
More Posts
Share by: